In 1974, Beverly Hills High School offered Theatre 40 a large storeroom—provided the company could transform it into a theatre. With grants from the City of Beverly Hills, the Beverly Hills Unified School District and the Ahmanson Foundation, together with the work of company members, the new theatre was created. The space was designed by acclaimed Broadway designer Ming Cho Lee.
Originally named in honor of Reuben Cordova, the theatre was renamed The Mary Levin Cutler Theatre in 2023. Mary Levin Cutler’s generous support helped Theatre 40 remain operational when many theatres were forced to close, and her commitment continues to sustain its future.